HB 1041: Deep Fakes in Elections

HB 1041 by Representative A. Collins

Summary:

This bill aims to prohibit the distribution of deceptive and fraudulent deepfakes in election communications in Arkansas. It defines deepfakes, outlines penalties for violations, and provides exceptions for certain uses.

Key Provisions:

  • Definitions:
    • Deceptive and fraudulent deepfake: Synthetic media that falsely alters or generates the speech, conduct, image, or likeness of a candidate or political party with the intent to harm their reputation or deceive voters. It must appear to a reasonable person to be real or significantly alter the impression of the candidate or party.
    • Synthetic media: An image, audio recording, or video recording that has been created or manipulated using technology like AI to create a realistic but false depiction.
  • Prohibition:
    • Prohibits distributing deceptive and fraudulent deepfakes of candidates or parties within 90 days of an election.
  • Disclosure Exception:
    • Allows distribution of deepfakes if they include a clear disclosure stating that the content has been manipulated or artificially generated.
    • Specifies requirements for the size, readability, and duration of the disclosure in visual and audio media.
  • Remedies and Penalties:
    • Candidates can seek injunctive relief to prevent the publication of deepfakes.
    • The State Board of Election Commissioners can impose civil penalties:
      • Up to $10,000 for repeat offenders.
      • Up to $5,000 for violations intended to cause violence or harm.
      • Up to $1,000 for other violations.
  • Exceptions:
    • The prohibition does not apply to:
      • News media: Bona fide newscasts, interviews, documentaries, or on-the-spot news coverage, as long as they acknowledge the deepfake's authenticity cannot be confirmed or if required by federal law.
      • Publications: Internet websites or periodicals that routinely carry news and commentary, if they state the deepfake's authenticity cannot be confirmed.
      • Satire or parody: Deepfakes that are clearly intended as satire or parody are allowed.

Explain It Like I'm 5

This proposed law wants to stop people from using fake videos, or "deepfakes", that could trick voters during elections. Deepfakes are videos that look real, but they've been changed using computers to make someone seem like they're saying or doing something they never did.

Here's the deal:

  • Deepfakes are a no-go: You can't share deepfakes of candidates or political parties within 90 days of an election if you're trying to hurt their reputation or trick voters.
  • Unless you say it's fake: If you really want to share a deepfake, you have to put a clear message on it saying that it's been changed or created artificially. Think of it like a big warning label!
  • Don't mess with elections: If you break this law, you could get in trouble. You might have to pay a fine, or a judge could even stop you from sharing the deepfake.
  • But some deepfakes are okay: Things like news reports, comedy skits, and stuff that's clearly a joke are okay. This law is all about protecting elections from people who want to spread lies.